Question: What is a Telly.
What is a Telly?
Carol to Jeff June 08?
----------------------------
Well it's British slang for a television. But I doubt that is what you are actually referring to. ;-)
The Telly are awards presented for video production. They are up to their 28th year of presenting awards.
Should you put any stock in the awards if the company you are talking with won one, is a good question. My answer would be no to maybe leaning on no. The Tellys are consider by many to be an award farm. The Tellys are graded on a curve, meaning there isn't just a single bronze, silver, gold winner as there is in events like the olympics or just one winner like the superbowl. There is actually a percentage of winners of gold, silver, bronze based on the number of entries, in each category. That to me isn't the best of the best. However maybe because there are a larger number of losers than winners. But honestly, they are predominantly a award farm that sells the statutes to the winners for $150 a pop, then encourages you to buy more statues of your winning category.
I'm sure someone who has won a Telly will have a different opinion than mine about their validity, but for me if the goal seems to be to sell you a statuette if you win, and many can win, then their selling awards not recognizing quality.
If you are looking for a social event or wedding videographer who's awards mean something, then I would look for winners of the WEVA Creative Excellence Awards. With the CEAs there is an entry fee, but the plaques for the winners are presented for free. And there are only 3 winners in each catagor, 1 taking gold, 1 taking silver, 1 taking bronze. There can be 1 or 2 honorable mentions for each catagory if the judges so decide, but these aren't presented on plaques but are certificates on paper.
And that point brings up a slight warning about some businesses ethics in this; if your videographer presents you with a CEA plaque make sure it says Gold, Silver or Bronze. I know of one "honorable mention" winner who has carved his certificate onto the same award that was used for the gold winners to appear more impressive. To me this is unethical and misleading to clients.
I consider the Creative Excellence Awards to be the equivalent of winning an Oscar in the wedding and event video industry. Far more impressive and difficult to win than the other awards like the Tellys. And due to this some videographers are willing to be less than honest to have something to impress their potential clients with. So if your potential vendor presents you with the sales pitch they have won a CEA in the past, I'd suggest going to WEVA's website to check, unfortunately they only list the present year's winners. Bridal Films is working on compiling a list of winners as far back as we can, along with as many of the videos as we can get permission to display. Presently we have the 2006 and 2007 winners listed.
So in conclusion, Creative Excellence Awards, impressive, all others not so much.
Hope this answers your question Carol.
Brian
Carol to Jeff June 08?
----------------------------
Well it's British slang for a television. But I doubt that is what you are actually referring to. ;-)
The Telly are awards presented for video production. They are up to their 28th year of presenting awards.
Should you put any stock in the awards if the company you are talking with won one, is a good question. My answer would be no to maybe leaning on no. The Tellys are consider by many to be an award farm. The Tellys are graded on a curve, meaning there isn't just a single bronze, silver, gold winner as there is in events like the olympics or just one winner like the superbowl. There is actually a percentage of winners of gold, silver, bronze based on the number of entries, in each category. That to me isn't the best of the best. However maybe because there are a larger number of losers than winners. But honestly, they are predominantly a award farm that sells the statutes to the winners for $150 a pop, then encourages you to buy more statues of your winning category.
I'm sure someone who has won a Telly will have a different opinion than mine about their validity, but for me if the goal seems to be to sell you a statuette if you win, and many can win, then their selling awards not recognizing quality.
If you are looking for a social event or wedding videographer who's awards mean something, then I would look for winners of the WEVA Creative Excellence Awards. With the CEAs there is an entry fee, but the plaques for the winners are presented for free. And there are only 3 winners in each catagor, 1 taking gold, 1 taking silver, 1 taking bronze. There can be 1 or 2 honorable mentions for each catagory if the judges so decide, but these aren't presented on plaques but are certificates on paper.
And that point brings up a slight warning about some businesses ethics in this; if your videographer presents you with a CEA plaque make sure it says Gold, Silver or Bronze. I know of one "honorable mention" winner who has carved his certificate onto the same award that was used for the gold winners to appear more impressive. To me this is unethical and misleading to clients.
I consider the Creative Excellence Awards to be the equivalent of winning an Oscar in the wedding and event video industry. Far more impressive and difficult to win than the other awards like the Tellys. And due to this some videographers are willing to be less than honest to have something to impress their potential clients with. So if your potential vendor presents you with the sales pitch they have won a CEA in the past, I'd suggest going to WEVA's website to check, unfortunately they only list the present year's winners. Bridal Films is working on compiling a list of winners as far back as we can, along with as many of the videos as we can get permission to display. Presently we have the 2006 and 2007 winners listed.
So in conclusion, Creative Excellence Awards, impressive, all others not so much.
Hope this answers your question Carol.
Brian
Labels: Creative Excellence Awards, Telly Award, WEVA
